Trace every component and outbound request
Draw the path from repository event to review comment, including queues, workers, model inference, embeddings, logs, and artifact storage. Mark each network boundary and credential. A locally installed connector can still transmit source code to an external model endpoint, depending on its configuration.
Ask vendors or maintainers for documented deployment diagrams and required endpoints. Validate the proposed setup with network controls and sanitized test traffic where feasible. Distinguish self-hosted application software, locally hosted inference, and a fully disconnected deployment; those are separate requirements with different operating consequences.
Evaluate the responsibilities you inherit
Assign owners for updates, model serving, capacity, vulnerability handling, backups, and repository credentials. Check supported hardware and deployment dependencies against your actual environment. A permissive source license does not remove the cost of administration or establish that the project is actively maintained.
Illustrative scenario: a small team installs a review worker inside its network but lacks an owner for model updates and queue failures. The selection should include an operational runbook and recovery exercise, not merely a successful first comment on a demonstration pull request.
Test review quality under the chosen deployment
Use representative changes to test the exact model, context window, and configuration you intend to host. Hosted-product demonstrations may use a different model or repository indexing capability. Compare useful findings, missed issues, runtime, and hardware use before assuming an on-premises deployment produces equivalent results.
Pilot least-privilege integration and credential rotation. Confirm what is retained in logs and indexes when a repository is removed. Keep the final decision tied to verified configuration and operating ownership; avoid blanket claims that a deployment is compliant or secure simply because it is local.
Working sheet
| Area | Question | Evidence to request |
|---|---|---|
| Inference | Where are prompts processed? | Endpoint and model configuration |
| Telemetry | Can source appear in logs? | Logging schema and controls |
| Operations | Who patches each component? | Ownership and update runbook |
| Licensing | What may we deploy and modify? | Actual component licenses |
| Quality | Does the local model find our issues? | Representative evaluation results |
Questions about evaluate self-hosted and on-premises AI code review tools
Does open source mean on-premises?
No. Source availability, deployment location, and licensing rights are different properties. Check each separately.
Is self-hosting automatically cheaper?
No. Include inference hardware, administration, patching, monitoring, and the effect of review quality on developer time.
How should I use the working sheet?
Download the CSV and replace the sample rows with evidence from your repository. Record a clear acceptance check and an owner for each item. Keep unresolved assumptions visible rather than treating the example as a completed assessment.
Sources and further reading
Examples are illustrative. They are not customer results, security guarantees, or a substitute for checking the documentation for your installed version.
