Write a refactoring brief with a stable contract
Describe the maintenance problem: duplicated rules, tangled dependencies, or a module that makes small changes expensive. Identify the behavior that must remain stable and the evidence available to check it. If the request includes new features or a different data model, separate those decisions from behavior-preserving restructuring.
Illustrative scenario: three endpoints calculate eligibility differently. Ask a candidate to map the existing rules and propose a shared boundary before consolidating them. A provider should investigate whether differences are intentional instead of automatically deleting apparent duplication and changing customer outcomes.
Evaluate the process behind the AI assistance
Ask who reviews generated changes, how repository context is selected, and where source code is processed. Request the proposed testing strategy and the treatment of ambiguous behavior. Tool access alone does not demonstrate domain understanding, and a large generated patch can increase your own review burden.
Compare a bounded sample using the same acceptance criteria across candidates. Inspect diff size, clarity of decisions, preserved contracts, and the effort your maintainers need to review it. Avoid judging by raw output volume or the speed of an initial demonstration without verification.
Agree on scope, acceptance, and ownership
Require deliverables such as reviewed commits, focused regression checks, and an explanation of the resulting module boundaries. Clarify who approves behavior changes, dependency updates, and production rollout. Keep access and data handling appropriate to the repository rather than assuming every provider uses the same deployment model.
A team can use Getzilla's open source workflow to plan and verify a refactoring task in an existing repository. That does not establish a consulting engagement or a promised duration. Larger rewrites or migrations need separate assessment, with delivery ownership and handover agreed with the actual provider.
Working sheet
| Criterion | Request | Evidence to assess |
|---|---|---|
| Behavior preservation | Explicit stable contracts | Before-and-after regression results |
| Domain understanding | Explanation of apparent duplication | Correct treatment of business exceptions |
| Human ownership | Named review responsibilities | Reviewed, understandable changes |
| Repository handling | Data flow and access policy | Approved scope and permissions |
| Handover | Boundary and decision notes | Maintainers can extend the result |
Questions about how to choose an AI-assisted code refactoring service
Which refactoring service is best?
Use a defined brief and comparable evidence. This guide offers selection criteria rather than fabricated provider rankings.
Can AI refactor an entire application automatically?
Automation may propose changes, but application-wide behavior and migration risks still require explicit verification and accountable review.
How should I use the working sheet?
Download the CSV and replace the sample rows with evidence from your repository. Record a clear acceptance check and an owner for each item. Keep unresolved assumptions visible rather than treating the example as a completed assessment.
Sources and further reading
Examples are illustrative. They are not customer results, security guarantees, or a substitute for checking the documentation for your installed version.
